Cookies, Cupcakes, and Cardio

Step by step homemade baking recipes

  • Home
  • Baking Bucket List
  • Recipes
    • Converting to Metric
  • About Me
    • What I Love to Love
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
  • Cookbook
  • Cakes
  • Cardio
    • Weights
    • Running
    • Spinning
    • Hiking
  • Cookies
  • Cupcakes
  • Tutorials
    • Videos
  • Other Baked Goodies
    • Holiday Baking
  • Randomness
    • What I’m Reading
    • The Beginning
    • Fortunate Fridays

Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich Cake

March 29, 2014 by Jenn

Favourite sandwich as a kid?  Definitely peanut butter and jelly!  My dad used to make us peanut butter and bologna, which sounds disgusting but strangely wasn’t, but PB&J always came in first.  Peanut butter and honey was a close second, and peanut butter and banana rounded up the top three.  In case you didn’t figure it out, obviously I have a love for peanut butter!  

This cake is such a fun one to surprise everyone with.  It’s giant, and seriously looks like a regular sized sandwich.  I’ve been planning to make a cake like this for a long time, so a couple months ago, I found a sandwich cake mold to use for it.  You definitely don’t need to have a special mold though.  It can easily be baked in a square pan (8″x8″) and when it has cooled, carve out the top with a couple of little notches and you’ll basically have the same thing.

I decided to make a peanut butter cake for the “bread” instead of a standard vanilla cake which would make the “bread” look like white bread.  The peanut butter cake makes the cake look like whole wheat “bread’, which is obviously healthier.  So this cake is healthy as it’s a sandwich made with whole wheat bread.  If you make it with vanilla cake, the white bread will go straight to your hips.  

 

 

[Read more...]

PinterestShare
Filed Under: Cakes, Tutorials, Videos Tagged With: april fool's day, cake filling, fruit filling, peanut butter, peanut butter and jelly, peanut butter and jelly sandwich cake, peanut butter cake, peanut butter filling, raspberry cake filling, raspberry filling, sandwich cake, trick food

Happiness is Homemade

Newsletter

Join my newsletter to keep updated on the latest tips and videos.

Sponsors

Join Me On:








Subscribe

Blogroll

  • Bake at 350
  • Keep It Sweet
  • Toronto Girl West

Tags

baking birthday birthday cake birthday cakes buttercream cake cake decorating cake design cake pops cake recipe cake recipes cakes cakes cranbrook candy candy cake chocolate chocolate cake Christmas cookies Cookies Cupcakes and Cardio Cranbrook cranbrook cakes cupcake cupcakes Cupcakes and Cardio dessert easter fondant Halloween homemade how-to how to make how to make cake Icing jenn johns jj's custom cakery No Bake peanut butter rainbow Rainbow cake recipe surprise inside surprise inside cake valentine's day wedding cake

Like Box

Site Stuff

  • RSS Feed Sign-Up
  • Privacy Policy

Google Plus

Return to top of page

Cookies, Cupcakes, and Cardio© 2019 • Design by Simply Chic Blog Boutique